Dear Counbinistas,
We have reached THE key moment election campaign. Not the dreary nonsense of the final Sunak v Starmer TV debate. And not the senile blithering of the first Trump v Biden debate*. No, I refer you to the most authoritative statistics programme on Planet Earth, More or Less on BBC Radio 4, presented by ace analyst Tim Harford.
Why? Because in the latest edition of this seminal series, Tim spends several minutes evaluating THE key policy of the 2024 General Election campaign: namely my pledge to price-cap croissants at £1.10. (You can hear the relevant section here, which was broadcast just after an item about human erections, by which I don’t mean skyscrapers.)
Exclusively for you, elite readers of Lifting The Lid, I am delighted to present my in-depth commentary on their in-depth commentary on my croissantary economics.
Tim Harford begins the item by stating that More or Less is committed to a ‘thorough examination of all the major political pledges’, which explains why he needs to examine the Croissant Price Cap (or CPC). It doesn’t explain why it’s taken several weeks for them to get to me, but I’ll let that pass.
Then we get into the real issues.
Tim Harford: Between April 2022 and April 2024, average food prices in the UK rose by more than 22%. It previously took almost 12 years for food prices to rise by the same amount.
Just take that in for a moment. There is the cost-of-living crisis distilled down to a single, shocking statistic. If you were the governing party when something like that was going on, you might expect at the next election to get the equivalent of a sharp knee to your psephological bollocks.
But hark, what is Tim’s next fact? ‘As a result, governments around the world have intervened in the market for food. Egypt spends billions of dollars subsidising bread, France and Greece have policies on the matter, and in February 2022 Hungary introduced a literal if temporary cap on the price of basics, including milk, sugar, flour, vegetable oil and eggs.’
So lookie what we have here - a planetary plethora of price-capping.
And what about in the fabled ‘United’ Kingdom? Tim has a curious fact about Blighty too: ‘In the UK, the government caps the price of journeys by train.’ Does it indeed? One would hate to imagine what the price of rail travel in Britain might be without the government’s existing benevolence.
Tim continues: ‘This croissant price-cap is well-chewed territory. But a price cap on croissants might have unintended consequences.’ Ahem, excuse me, Mr Harford. Firstly, if the CPC is so well-chewed, why is it having such continued galactic resonance amongst the voting public? And secondly, ‘unintended consequences’? Au contraire, old bean. Au contraire.
All my consequences are intended. I have stochastic capabilities and I know precisely what my croissant policy will entail, right down to the fact that it sent Tim to talk to Professor Paul Dobson, an economist at the University of East Anglia.
Tim asked the professor what would happen if the CPC were implemented, and the beginning of their conversation revolved around the issue of trying ‘to define a croissant’. You know what a croissant is. I’m an alien and I know what a croissant is. But here, on the BBC, two esteemed academics were tying themselves and each other up in pastry knots about it. This is precisely why you need a space warrior to handle these things.
Next, Tim and Paul speculate about croissants disappearing or deteriorating in quality, or a black market developing whereby:
Tim: You order your sliced white bread and if there’s a nod and a wink the baker will reach under the counter and pull out the croissant, but the man from the government doesn’t need to know about that.’
Prof Dobson: That’s quite right…
It’s at this point where Tim momentarily seems to lose his compass for economic rationality, as he says ‘It all sounds like this may not be an entirely serious policy.’
WOAH THERE, BBC MAN. Watch your lip. As I heard Tim say this, for a scintilla of a space-second I thought about turning my lasers on Broadcasting House - such that the answer to the question ‘More or Less’ would be a definitive ‘less’. But I didn’t need to retaliate. Prof Paul Dobson had the stats to back me up. Get a load of this:
Prof Dobson: I think this price cap as a suggestion seems to have worked. I did a quick spot-check on the market today and I saw that Tesco and Sainsbury’s and Waitrose were pricing their croissants at £1.10. So they’d obviously gone to the price-cap. (But I was dismayed to find at least one of those retailers selling an almond croissant at £1.40.)
There it is, people. Not my words. The words of a professor of economics at the University of East Anglia. British supermarkets are reacting to my price cap, and saving YOU money. (Ignore the almond croissant. I’ll come to that in a future manifesto.)
As if this endorsement isn’t seismic enough, Tim Harford goes a step further in his response:
Tim: I mean, this is interesting. So Count Binface is really invoking the power of Nobel laureate Thomas Schelling - the power of the Focal Point - where he basically, merely by making this a very public declaration of intent, he is shaming the supermarkets into co-ordinating on £1.10, because anyone who prices more than £1.10, people will see that and go “Well, Binface wouldn’t stand for this” and they’ll just look bad.
Prof Dobson: That’s quite right.
And there you have it. The Count Binface Manifesto is literally, actually, saving pastry-loving Brits money by dint of just saying the policy, let alone enforcing it. That’s the power of Binface.
As a short addendum, I freely admit that Professor Dobson concludes his analysis by describing the CPC as an ‘extreme’ measure (I disagree with that, obvs) but offers an alternative solution by suggesting that the Count Binface Party could introduce a ‘state-sponsored croissant’ into the market, to affect prices that way. Professor Dobson, if you read this (which of course you will), I want you to know that this intergalactic space warrior is in listening mode, and I am prepared to meet with you and discuss the merits of setting up Great British Croissants as a government-run bridging point, on the pathway towards the £1.10 target. Consider the all-butter gauntlet thrown down.
I think we can all agree that the rest of the 2024 General Election has been cast entirely into the shadow by the fact that I, Count Binface, have officially affected the UK bakery market and single-handedly defeated the beast of inflation, in a way that Rishi could only dream of.
I’ll be back with more Substack splendour next week. Till then, you can fill your bins with more intergalactic fun via my podcast Trash Talk (new guests include Simon McCoy and Paul from Traitors). And tickets are now on sale for my debut comedy tour this autumn! Come see me by clicking here.
Last but not least, if you want to dress the part for election day, the wizards at Balcony Shirts, Uxbridge have created an incredible range of Binface merch at www.binfaceshop.co.uk, with 50% of proceeds going to Shelter to help combat homelessness.
Peace and galactic love,
CB x
*Since this embarrassing TV moment for the ages, when Trump and Biden seemed more interested in their golf handicap than leading America, I have been asked several times what is my golf handicap? My answer is: the bin, mainly.
Promoted by Count Binface, PO Box 731, Wadhurst, TN5 6TD, Earth


